Thursday, April 19, 2012

Saucony Kinvara 3 Review: The People's Shoe

Say what you will about Vibrams and other barefoot shoes, personally I think the Saucony Kinvara may have done as much for acceptance of “minimalist” shoes and the increased focus on running form as any other shoe out there. Blessed with barely-there upper, a modest 4mm heel-to-toe ramp angle to promote midfoot striking, a full-contact outsole, and a very light overall weight, the Kinvara is a well-cushioned, but largely minimalist shoe.

The original Kinvara became my own long-run shoe once I had transitioned to running in Vibrams and barefoot, which is pretty amazing considering that a few years ago, something like the Kinvara would have been recommended only for the “mechanically gifted neutral runner” or something like that.


Well, I am not mechanically gifted, but I am a neutral runner in that I really don’t overpronate, according to the high-speed cameras at Elite Feet. I don’t even care, honestly, because I think the myth that overpronaton causes injuries is actually that, a myth. After all, I am sure there were overpronating cavemen. I digress, we aren’t here to argue about barefoot vs. shod running. We are talking about a shoe. A great shoe, in fact.

The Kinvara 3 is a full update of the well-known, very well loved Kinvara and Kinvara 2 (which were largely the same except for a few minor upper details). The Kinvara 3 does it right, properly updating a proven classic, fixing its few flaws and maintaining its many fine qualities. The light weight is still there, as are the low drop and minimal upper. The outsole and midsole are similar, but tweaked for durability and ride. The looks? Amazing. This shoe is going to come in some amazing colorways, and Saucony provided us with a stunning black/green fade that makes most hyper greens look dull by comparison.

Many folks criticized the Kinvara’s original chassis for its lack of durability, Made for midfoot striking, the Kinvara actually lacked good blown rubber outsole material along the outside midfoot area, up and down from the little toe, where ground contact was the most consistent for good-form runners. This version fixes that with a new outsole design.

They actually took away blown rubber where testing showed it was not necessary, but added it in critical spots like the one I described. Look close, though, some of the durable rubber is white like the exposed midsole, so you are forgiven for mistakenly assuming they did not add material there. At any rate, this new version will undoubtedly get more miles than the old ones.

The upper defies description. Made up of a web of welded overlays on a soft, meshy base material, the whole upper feels sock-like and comfortable. I suppose it would even work sockless for many, but I prefer thin socks for a shoe like this and I was not disappointed. No hotspots, plenty of wiggle room for my narrow feet (your mileage may vary here...if you were snug in the old ones, you will still be in these, I think). The toe shape is still sort of pointy, but it feels less pronounced in the Kinvara 3. I love the way these shoes look and feel on my feet. Great job there.

The midsole is thick and really elevates the runner off the ground. To combat this, the midsole/outsole chassis is really wide for stability. You won’t roll your ankle or anything in these, unlike some narrow-midsole shoes that are thickly cushioned (lots of lightweight Adidas, for instance, are like that...narrow and high and squishy...actually augmenting pronation). The ride on the Kinvara is not as soft as you might imagine, it is sort of mid-firm. It provides a decent base without sacrificing cushion, and it still manages to be pretty flexible.

Finally, cost. These guys are going to be around $100, and with the added outsole durability you should get your money’s worth. Just check out the clever “cost per mile” calculator set up by my friend Thomas on his blog entry about the Kinvara 3 on Believe in the Run. Genius.

The Kinvara 3 just doesn't offend in any way.  To me,it is a workaday hero without any real downsides.  It is a bit thick, sure, but it is a full-cushion shoe, not truly a barefooter's shoe.  On the whole it is a likable, guy-next-door. It will fit just about anyone (but it does have high arches and the toebox is a try-before-you-buy proposition).

I think Saucony did a great, conservative job with this update. I found nothing objectionable in the Kinvara 3, and I was a die-hard supporter of the original. It breathes, rides, and allows natural running form. It is more durable, still affordable, and looks even cooler than the original. It permits traditional runners to dabble in the minimalist market with its low-drop option and light weight. It serves as a marathon race shoe, distance trainer, 5k-pr shoe, and so much more. Many runners at many levels have embraced the Kinvara in all of its forms for a wide variety of applications. If you run barefoot, this may be your most built-up shoe. If you run in heavy-duty stability trainers, this may be your race day shoe. It can fill a niche in almost any runner’s closet, and is probably the only shoe I have seen (no lie) on a heavy-set, aging mall-walker, a marathon finisher (and Boston qualifier, no less), and a fast 5k race winner.

The Kinvara 3, in other words, is the people’s shoe.


The Kinvara 3 will be available soon at Elite feet and retailers nationwide.  Test shoe provided by Saucony.









9 comments:

Surfing Vol said...

Nice review! I've pre-ordered a pair.

Happy running.

Brad

Neil said...

Zach, great to have you back - I was getting concerned. Great review as usual. Do you know when you will be posting your review of teh Skora Base?
Thanks,
Neil

Zak said...

Neil- Thanks for your concern and readership! I moved across the State and started a new job, sold a house, bought a house, etc...I was busy! Anyway, I am not sure if I will post a review of the Skora Base soon, as I have not sent much time in them. They are a very, very differet shoe from the Form (which I love) and unfortunately my experience with them has not been entirely positive. Fit is a real issue with the Base in my opinion, and in the opinion of some shop owners I know who are having trouble selling that model to folks (very high volume midfoot, but a tapered, somewhat snug forefoot, an odd combo). In my case I had to take them to a cobbler to have the straps shortened just to get it secure on my feet. I paid full retail for the Base (which shows you how excited I was about them!) but so far they are not a running shoe I have been able to warm to. They look cool, they breathe well, but they are just not the shoe that the much more expensive Form is, in my opinion.

Neil said...

Zak, thanks for the detailed response and glad things are going well, all be they hectic. I just need to decide whether to plunk down the cash on the Form without trying them on becuase there are no local dealers in the Philadelphia area. I am also concerned about performance of the Form during our hot humid summer months, although I guess I could just use them as a fall and winter shoe.
Thanks again,
Neil

Zak said...

That might be teh achilles heel of the For (warm weather). I can't say yet because I vaen't had a chance to spend much time in them in warm weather. I will say that I do sweat in them a good bit and the leather becomes sort of saturated, but it stays piable and soft, and dries overnight pretty well.

Neil said...

Thanks again. Still looking to add a shoe to my rotation, but may need to go with The People's Shoe or possibly the forthcoming Skechers Go Bionic.

Mike said...

I got myself a pair at the London Expo, before the Marathon. I have since put some miles on them. Great shoe and a good step up from the 2's. My only irritation is the sizing. It seems that they are sized even larger than the 2's and they are one size larger than anything else on the market. Not sure that is really necessary, especially for all those who order by mail!

fitnessat50 said...

Zak, thanks for this review. I was just wondering if I wanted to get another pair of Kinvaras for the summer. I really like my originals but they're about done. Sounds like the new model is a winner!

How are you doing in your new digs? Going to visit the PR Fitness group anytime soon?

Jeff

Zak said...

Jeff! Sorry I missed this comment, great to hear from you! My running has been sporadic and racing has been limited to some local 5ks up here. The new Kinvara IS a great hit. Feels the same underfoot, but that improved upper is fantastic. If you like 1 and 2, you'll like 3. I hope to run again with PR sometime, but yeah, we've really sort of gone off the radar and made a lot of new friends and things up here. My new job is fantastic, but very time consuming as well. Take care!